Smoked pepper cheddar sandwich with caramelized onion
A grownup open-faced cheese toast that leans on the smoke and pepper already in the cheese. The onion underneath turns sweet and soft while the bread toasts, so everything cooks together in one pan. Two thick sandwiches, ready in twenty minutes.
About 640 calories a serving, 26 g protein, 37 g carbohydrate, 43 g fat. From USDA figures for 100% of the ingredients; amounts are the recipe's.
To buy
- 4 slices thick bread (sourdough or pullman)
From your shelf
- 6 oz (170 g) smoked black pepper natural white cheddar cheese, deli sliced (Tillamook)
Staples
- 2 tablespoons butter
- 1 medium onion
- to taste salt
- to taste pepper
- Slice 1 medium onion thin and melt 2 tablespoons butter in a skillet over medium heat. Add the onion and a pinch of salt, then stir often until the onion softens and turns gold at the edges, about 8 minutes.
- Push the onion to the sides of the skillet and lay 4 slices of thick bread flat in the center. Toast each side over medium heat until light gold, about 2 minutes per side, while you finish the onion.
- Divide the caramelized onion between 2 toasts on their side of the skillet. Lay 3 oz (85 g) of the smoked pepper cheese over each pile of onion, then cover the skillet with a lid or foil and reduce heat to medium-low. The cheese will melt in 1 to 2 minutes; you will see it start to glisten.
Note Swap the onion for sliced tomato if you need this faster, or roasted mushrooms if you have them. Leftovers keep two days in the fridge and reheat in a hot skillet. Serve with a simple salad of bitter greens and sharp vinaigrette, or a bowl of tomato soup.
On the label
CULTURED PASTEURIZED MILK, SALT, ENZYMES, SMOKED BLACK PEPPERCORN (BLACK PEPPERCORN, NATURAL SMOKE FLAVORS).
Tillamook, cheese, serving 20 g, package 7 oz/198 g. Ingredients as printed on the label.
More from Tillamook
- Tillamook sharp cheddar & uncured bacon mac & cheese, sharp cheddar & uncured bacon
- Tillamook sharp cheddar & uncured bacon jumbo macaroni in a velvety sauce of aged sharp white cheddar and monterey jack topped with more cheese, uncured bacon bites and crispy onions mac & cheese, sharp cheddar & uncured bacon
- Tillamook classic cheddar jumbo macaroni in a creamy sauce of aged medium and sharp cheddar topped with more cheese and the crunch of crushed pretzel and herbs mac & cheese, classic cheddar
- Tillamook cheesy bbq chicken recipe chopped white-meat chicken, red onions and cilantro over whole-milk mozzarella, award-winning yellow cheddar, and monterey jack plus tangy bbq sauce on a crispy stone-fired crust pizza, cheesy bbq chicken recipe
- Tillamook three cheese a melty three-cheese blend of whole-milk mozzarella, award-winning yellow cheddar and monterey jack, plus savory red sauce on a crispy stone-fired crust crispy stone-fired pizza, three cheese
- Tillamook three cheese supreme crispy stone-fired pizza uncured pepperoni and italian sausage sprinkled with peppers and onions over whole-milk mozzarella, award-winning yellow cheddar and monterey jack on a crispy stone-fired crust, three cheese supreme
- Tillamook sharp cheddar cheese
- Tillamook white cheddar cheese, garlic
- Tillamook cheddar cheese, medium smoked
- Tillamook dessert yogurt, salted caremel
Other cheddar
- Henning's Wisconsin Cheese cajun cheddar cheese curdsHenning's Wisconsin Cheese
- Jimmy Dean smoked ham and sharp cheddar cheese on a pretzel roll sandwiches, smoked hamJimmy Dean
- Jimmy Dean hickory smoked turkey applewood smoked bacon and sharp cheddar cheese on a honey wheat bun sandwiches, hickory smoked turkeyJimmy Dean
- Kretschmar mild cheddar natural cheese, mild cheddarKretschmar
- Cabot premium vermont sharp cheddar cheese cracker cut slices, vermont sharp cheddarCabot
- Hot Pockets four cheese pizza with parmesan, cheddar and reduced fat provolone & mozzarella cheeses in a flaky crust snack bites sandwiches, four cheese pizzaHot Pockets
- Hot Pockets applewood bacon cheddar cheese melt with tomatoes in pretzel bread sandwiches, applewood bacon cheddar cheese meltHot Pockets
- Stouffer's loaded cheddar potato bake diced potatoes in a creamy cheddar cheese sauce accented with chives & bacon cups, loaded cheddar potato bakeStouffer's
- Trenton Farms cheddar cheese sauce, cheddar cheeseTrenton Farms
- Hot Pockets hickory ham & cheddar with reduced fat cheddar cheese & sauce in a crispy buttery crust sandwiches, hickory ham & cheddarHot Pockets
Cooks as cheddar, black pepper. Half of it left? Use up the cheddar.